19 November 2026
We spend a great deal of time talking about the challenges facing our schools, from funding pressures and workforce shortages to increasing accountability and the changing needs of pupils and communities. But perhaps one of the most important questions we should be asking is who will actually want to lead our schools in the future?
It was this question that brought together a panel at the recent Confederation of School Trusts (CST) Annual Conference, where I was joined by Claire Heald, CEO of The CAM Academy Trust, Andrea Mitchell, Principal of Oasis Academy Leesbrook, and Andrew Thraves, Chair of Trustees at Big Education Trust, to explore the future of headship.
What became clear through our discussion was that this is about much more than succession planning. We need to think seriously whether the role of headteacher, as it exists today, is one that we are preparing people for, supporting them in and, perhaps most importantly, inspiring them to aspire to.
The reality is that headship has changed considerably over the past decade. We expect today’s headteachers to be outstanding educationalists, strategic thinkers, people leaders, financial decision-makers, community ambassadors and experts in safeguarding, operations and risk. As I reflected during the session, “We haven’t removed anything from the Head’s job. We have simply kept adding to it.” And yet, despite this fundamental shift, many of our approaches to identifying, developing and recruiting school leaders remain remarkably traditional.
At Anderson Quigley, our work across the education sector increasingly highlights the breadth of capabilities now required of school leaders. Alongside teaching and learning, heads need to demonstrate strategic vision, commercial awareness, emotional intelligence, stakeholder engagement and the ability to lead through complexity. The headteacher is no longer simply the leader of a school, but increasingly the leader of a school community, operating within a much wider and more demanding environment.
Andrea Mitchell brought this into sharp focus through her experience as Principal of Oasis Academy Leesbrook. Her contribution reminded us that behind every discussion about leadership structures and succession planning is the reality of what it feels like to lead a school. As Andrea reflected:
“Headship today is about so much more than leading teaching and learning. You are leading people, managing complexity and responding to the needs of an entire school community. We need to move away from the expectation that the Head has to carry everything. The strongest schools are those where leadership is genuinely shared, where teams are empowered and where future leaders are given the confidence and opportunity to grow.”
This point is particularly important. We have created a culture in which headship can sometimes appear to be about carrying an extraordinary level of personal responsibility, often with limited space to step away from the immediate operational challenges and focus on the longer-term development of the school.
For aspiring leaders looking at those already in the role, we have to ask ourselves whether what they see is something they genuinely want for their own careers. There is also an important distinction between developing good senior leaders and preparing people for headship. We can give individuals responsibility for curriculum, behaviour, safeguarding or school improvement, but are we giving them the opportunity to understand the wider strategic, financial and organisational responsibilities that come with leading a school?
This was an area that Claire Heald explored through the work taking place at The CAM Academy Trust. Recognising the challenges around leadership succession, the trust has taken a deliberate approach to developing its future headteachers, creating clearer pathways and opportunities for aspiring leaders to build their experience beyond their immediate roles. As Claire explained:
“We recognised that we couldn’t simply wait for the next headteacher vacancy and hope that the right person would emerge. We needed to be much more deliberate about identifying talent, creating opportunities and supporting people on their journey towards headship. That means looking beyond formal qualifications and giving aspiring leaders the practical experiences, networks and confidence they need to take that next step.”
What I particularly liked about Claire’s approach was the recognition that leadership development cannot simply be a series of qualifications or training programmes. The NPQH provides an important foundation, but it cannot fully prepare someone for the complexities of leading an organisation, managing difficult decisions or navigating the competing expectations of staff, parents, trustees and the wider community. That confidence and experience have to be built over time.
Trusts have a real opportunity here. Through their scale, networks and organisational structures, they can expose aspiring leaders to different school contexts, strategic projects, governance, financial decision-making and opportunities to work beyond their own settings. This is about creating a much richer understanding of what headship involves before someone is expected to step into the role.
Andrew Thraves brought another important dimension to the conversation from his perspective as Chair of Trustees at Big Education Trust. If we are serious about attracting and retaining exceptional leaders, then boards also need to consider the environments they are creating for those individuals to succeed. We often focus heavily on the person we want to appoint, but perhaps not enough on the role we are asking them to undertake.
As trusts evolve, there is an opportunity to rethink the relationship between the headteacher, the central executive team and the board. What responsibilities genuinely need to sit with the head? Where can specialist expertise provide greater support? And how do we ensure that accountability is matched by the autonomy, resources and capacity needed to lead effectively? These questions are not simply about organisational efficiency; they go directly to the attractiveness and sustainability of headship.
From a recruitment perspective, I also believe we need to challenge some of our long-held assumptions about what a future headteacher should look like. Too often, recruitment processes still place considerable emphasis on previous job titles, established career routes and the reputation of the organisations someone has worked for. Of course, experience matters, but it is not always the best predictor of someone’s ability to lead successfully in a changing environment.
If the role has evolved so significantly, why are we still recruiting heads in largely the same way?
We should be looking much more closely at evidence of leadership capability, how individuals make decisions, build relationships, manage complexity, develop teams and respond to challenge. We also need to be more open-minded about where talent comes from and recognise that some of our strongest future leaders may not have followed the most conventional route to headship.
This is something we have been exploring through our competency framework at Anderson Quigley, looking at the different dimensions of leadership required in today’s schools and how we can assess those more meaningfully through the recruitment process.
But recruitment is only one part of the equation. Perhaps the greatest challenge facing the sector is what I would describe as the aspiration gap. There are undoubtedly talented individuals within our schools who have the capability to become excellent headteachers, but who are increasingly questioning whether they want the role.
The reasons are understandable. Workload, accountability, personal risk, work-life balance, confidence and the perception of headship all play a part. We cannot expect to address these concerns simply by encouraging more people to apply or by improving the way we advertise vacancies – we have to make headship a role that people want to do.
That means ensuring that current heads feel supported, that aspiring leaders have opportunities to experience the role before taking it on and that trusts are actively investing in their future talent. It also means being prepared to challenge whether our existing leadership structures are fit for purpose. What I found encouraging about the discussion at CST was the recognition that these challenges are not insurmountable. Andrea’s focus on shared leadership and developing people within schools, Claire’s proactive approach to building a leadership pipeline and Andrew’s governance perspective all demonstrated that there are practical steps we can take now.
There is also a responsibility on those of us working in executive search to help boards think differently about the capabilities they need, challenge traditional recruitment assumptions and identify talent that might otherwise be overlooked. Ultimately, we need to move away from treating succession planning as something that happens when a headteacher announces they are leaving. Developing future leaders should be a continuous, strategic priority, embedded in the way trusts operate and the opportunities they create for their people.
We should also be doing far more to celebrate the privilege and impact of headship. Despite its challenges, it remains one of the most influential leadership roles in our society, offering the opportunity to shape communities, develop people and make a lasting difference to the lives of young people. If we want the next generation of talented educators to aspire to headship, we need to ensure that this is the story they see and experience.
The question is no longer simply whether we have enough people ready to become headteachers. It is whether we are creating the right roles, development opportunities and conditions for them to want to lead. The future of headship should not be about finding people willing to carry an ever-growing burden. It should be about creating a model of leadership in which exceptional people can thrive, and where the next generation can genuinely see themselves.

Also by Hayley Mintern: Beyond the HR Handbook: Why Independent Schools Need to Rethink Their Workforce
Hayley Mintern specialises in executive search and leadership advisory services for independent schools, international schools, academy trusts and education groups across the UK and internationally.
Combining extensive sector relationships with a research-led approach to executive search, Hayley brings a particular interest in leadership capability, succession planning, governance and the changing skills required to lead successful schools. Through Anderson Quigley’s wider advisory capabilities, she helps clients look beyond traditional recruitment models to consider leadership assessment, organisational structure and long-term talent development. Connect with Hayley on LinkedIn or email her at hayley.mintern@andersonquigley.com